Showing posts with label FERC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label FERC. Show all posts

Solar growth explodes in October

SUBHEAD: 99.3 percent of all new electric generation placed in service during the month of October came from renewables - mostly solar.

By Rhone Resch on 26 November 2013 for EcoWatch -
(http://ecowatch.com/2013/11/25/solar-growth-explodes-october/)


Image above: Residential installation of solar PV panels. Twelve new solar projects accounted for 504MegaWatts or 72.1% of all new capacity last month in the U.S., according to the Solar Energy Industries Association (SEIA). From original article.

Even though they were overshadowed by the Senate’s historic decision to eliminate the use of the filibuster when it comes to most Presidential nominees—the so-called “nuclear option”—there were some major developments this week at the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) that are critically important to solar and renewable energy.

First, FERC Chairman Jon Wellinghoff, who proclaimed earlier this year that, “solar is growing so fast it is going to overtake everything,” announced that he’s officially leaving his position at the end of the week. Chairman Wellinghoff has been a true champion to solar, and we wish him well in all of his new endeavors.

But before leaving, Wellinghoff presided over one last Commission meeting on Thursday as a new rule was approved by FERC that will expedite and reduce the cost of solar project interconnections, while maintaining the reliability and safety of the electric grid. In a nutshell, this action—which SEIA has championed for nearly two years—will help to spur new solar deployment nationwide. The rule was approved by a 4-0 vote with Chairman Wellinghoff abstaining because of a possible conflict of interest.

Here’s the back story. In 2005, FERC issued Order No. 2006, which—for the first time—established national interconnection procedures applicable to generation projects that are 20 megawatts (MW) or less in size and subject to FERC’s wholesale jurisdiction. Order No. 2006 was groundbreaking at the time, and the procedures were voluntarily adopted by many states to also apply to the retail interconnection process.

However, demand for solar energy has grown dramatically since the original order was issued more than seven years ago, and certain aspects of the order have resulted in needless barriers to cost-effective and timely interconnections.

The approved rule will allow solar projects that meet certain technical requirements to qualify for a “fast track” interconnection process, thus eliminating the need for costly and time-consuming studies. Most importantly, today’s decision will help to reduce interconnection bottlenecks.

As an association, we applaud FERC for recognizing the challenges facing wholesale distributed generation development, which is one of the fastest-growing segments of America’s solar energy industry. But it’s important to point out that the new rule also maintains electric system safety and reliability, making it a win all the way around.

This is the way government should work. We deeply appreciate FERC’s open-minded approach and willingness to revisit this issue based on unforeseen developments. We look forward to working with FERC and all other interested stakeholders in the future to help further the deployment of clean, reliable and affordable solar energy nationwide. SEIA is also urging state regulators to consider using FERC’s new rule as a model and starting point for updating their own interconnection rules.

And, finally, this brings me to the other really good news coming out of FERC this week. According to the agency’s Energy Infrastructure Update report, 99.3 percent of all new electric generation placed in service during the month of October came from renewables—with solar leading the way by a country mile!

Twelve new solar units accounted for 504 MW or 72.1 percent of all new capacity last month. This is truly astonishing, not to mention historic, and should serve as a reminder to everyone in Washington and in state capitals that smart public policies—such as the solar Investment Tax Credit (ITC), Net Energy Metering (NEM) and Renewable Portfolio Standards (RPS)—are paying huge dividends for America.

Today, solar is one of the fastest-growing sources of new energy in the United States. More than 30 utility-scale, clean energy solar projects are still under construction, putting thousands of electricians, steelworkers and laborers to work and helping to reduce carbon emissions from power plants. These facilities, along with rooftop solar on homes, businesses and schools, will generate electricity for generations to come.

There are now more than 9,400 megawatts (MW) of cumulative solar electric capacity installed in the U.S. —enough to power more than 1.5 million American homes—and that number is expected to hit nearly 13,000 MW by the end of this year.

In addition, SEIA recently released a comprehensive new report outlining ways to create 50,250 new American jobs and save more than $61 billion in future energy costs by expanding the use of innovative and cost-effective solar heating and cooling (SHC) systems across the nation.

Today, solar employs nearly 120,000 Americans at more than 6,100 companies, most of which are small businesses spread across the United States, making solar one of the fastest-growing industries in America. Part of this amazing growth is attributed to the fact that the cost of a solar system has dropped by nearly 40 percent over the past two years, making solar more affordable—and more popular—than ever. And as solar continues to scale up, costs will continue to come down.

So in a week filled with high drama on Capitol Hill, you could say that solar—in its own unique way—has become the new “nuclear option” when it comes to helping America meet its future energy needs.
.

FFP Makaweli Hydro Project Ends

SOURCE: Brad Parsons (mauibrad@hotmail.com)
SUBHEAD: Free Flow Power has surrendered its permit to develop Makaweli River basin hydroelectric project.

By Daniel Lissner on 28 May 2013 for Free Flow Power -
(http://elibrary.ferc.gov/idmws/file_list.asp?accession_num=20130528-5160)


Image above: Photo of Makaweli Rover Valley by S Shoys. From (http://www.flickr.com/photos/sshoys/5527887821/lightbox/).

May 28, 2013

Kimberly Bose
Secretary Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
888 First Street, N. E. Washington, DC 20426

Re:  Request to Surrender Preliminary Permit for Project No. 13879 – Makaweli River Hydroelectric Project

Dear Secretary Bose:

On May 20, 2011, the Commission issued to Kahawai Power 2, LLC at Preliminary Permit with respect to the Makaweli River Hydroelectric Project, No. 13879-000 (the “Project”).

Free Flow Power Corporation (“FFP”), on behalf of Kahawai Power 2, LLC, hereby petitions the Commission, pursuant to 18 C.F.R. § 4.84, to approve the voluntary surrender of the Preliminary Permit for the Project.

In the course of investigating the feasibility of the Project and consultation with landowners and stakeholders pursuant to the Preliminary Permit, FFP, in cooperation with Kauai Island Utility Cooperative (“KIUC”), evaluated the compatibility of the Project with development activities that are currently underway by Gay & Robinson, Inc., an intervenor in this Project and the owners of lands on which the majority of the Project is proposed to be located.

FFP and KIUC understand that Gay & Robinson, Inc. is currently in the process of developing the Olokele Hydro Project on the Olokele Ditch, which is fed by the Olokele River and, like the Project, is also located in the Makaweli River Basin.

While the two projects are not in direct competition for the same water resources, FFP and KIUC are ceasing plans to pursue the Project in consideration of Gay & Robinson’s development efforts.

Accordingly, FFP respectfully requests that the Commission accept its surrender of the Preliminary Permit and order its termination prior to its scheduled expiration date of April 30, 2014.
If you have any questions regarding this filing, please do not hesitate to contact me at 978-252-7111.
Sincerely,

Daniel N. Lissner
General Counsel
Free Flow Power Corporation

See also:
Ea O Ka Aina: Nay No! to KIUC-FFP Deal 6/13/11

.

Hanalei Hydro-Electric

SOURCE: Brad Parsons (kauaibrad@hotmail.com)
SUBHEAD: Letter from Kauai conservation group to Free Flow Power concerning Hanalei River hydro-electric  project.

[IB Editor's note: The following is the content of a letter to Dawn Huff of Free Flow Power concerning a hanalei River hydroelectric project from Barbara Robeson, the president of the Limu Coalition, that was provided as a PDF file from Brad Parsons.]

By Barbara Robeson on 23 October 2012 in Island Breath -
(http://islandbreath.blogspot.com/2012/10/hanalei-hydroelectric.html)


Image above: View from a kayak paddling up the Hanalei River on Kauai. From (http://traveltamed.com/most-gorgeous-rivers-on-earth/).

20121022-0013 FERC PDF (Unofficial) 10/22/2012

October 12, 2012

Dawn Huff
Free Flow Power
2200 Rimland Drive, Suite 104
Bellingham, WA 98226

Re:    P-13878 —Hanalei Hydroelectric Project Third Six Month Progress Report

Dear Ms. Huff,

The Limu Coalition received your letter of October 4, 2012 letter regarding the Hanalei River Hydroelectric Project. The attachments to the letter stated that:

  1. "…several alternative project layouts have been evaluated with various diversion locations, water conveyance designs and alignments. " May we please have a copy of these alternative project documents?
  2. "Project sizing and generation estimate activities have been completed. .. May we also have a copy of this documentation?

The attached letter also states that "several outreach meetings have been undertaken over the last eight months". Please provide information about which non-governmental organizations you met with. The Limu Coalition which is located in Hanalei was not included in any of these meetings.

Sincerely yours,
Barbara Robeson President
Limu Coalition
PO Box 369 Hanalei, Hl 96714

c:
Kimberly Bose, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Hui Ho'omalu i ka'Aina
Hanalei to Ha'ena Community Association
Hanalei Watershed Hui

The purpose of the Limu Coalition is to promote the preservation of the natural, cultural and historic resources of the North Shore of Kaua'i.

See also:
Ea O Ka Aina: KIUC/FFP denied by FERC 10/20/11
Ea O Ka Aina: FERC Flim Flam 6/30/11
Ea O Ka Aina: KIUC Wailua Dam Plans 1/17/11
.

Ben Dover Time

SUBHEAD: Ben's a nice guy and we're sure he actually believes in what he says and what he does. Buuttt... By Andy Parx on 8 December 2011 for Parx News Daily - (http://parxnewsdaily.blogspot.com/2011/12/its-ben-dover-time.html) Image above: Mashup of Bernad and Ben by Juan Wilson. From (http://www.midweekkauai.com/2011/09/aloha-ike-fundraiser/kmwpaina091411_20/). Our "extra" post yesterday- a news item on Ben Sullivan's hiring by the county to be the new Energy Coordinator- was confirmed in a county press release today. But apparently others weren't as caught off guard as we were. We heard from quite a few readers saying that they were Casablanca-style "shocked-shocked" that Sullivan parlayed his short stints as founder and head of Apollo Kaua`i and election to the Kaua`i Island Utilities Coop (KIUC) Board of Directors into a well-paid job in the administration of Mayor Bernard Carvalho, Jr. But looking back on Sullivan's rise from FOB malahini to appointment to Carvalho's crony-filled staff shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone who watches the administration's hiring practices and has interacted with Sullivan since his election to the KIUC board. We began getting them soon after Sullivan's election- emails, comments and phone calls increasingly expressing disillusionment and dissatisfaction with Sullivan's apparent unwavering shift from perceived dissident to KIUC defender of the realm. It came to a head with his support for the whole FERC-FFP deal followed by the propaganda- some say misinformation- driven vote that allowed the co-op to go ahead with federal involvement in hydropower projects rather than rejecting FERC in favor of strictly state oversight... especially given the potential for federal "trumping" of the more environmentally-protective local regulations and approval process. But that alone wouldn't be enough to be a "good fit" for the yes-men and women that kow-tow to Carvalho, in an administration where "never is heard a discouraging word" from appointees... or at least not if they expect to serve in their "at-the-pleasure-of" positions for long. Sullivan didn't just support board decisions as is required under KIUC rules- he firecely defended them. Board Rule 27 mandates lock-step public adherence to board-determined positions and policies and requires all public statements by board members to be cleared by either the chair or (get this) the CEO. The latter creates a potentially unethical if not illegal situation whereby employees of the not-for-profit are directing members of the board. He has seemingly relished engaging members of the public in support of those positions and dove in head-first in a rare-for-Kaua`i trait of personal engagement with dissidents... of which there are many when it comes to the electricity coop. And that is what has made Sullivan a perfect fit for the Carvalho administration. It seems to matter not that he is an architect by education and, although his non-profit work has dealt with electrical power issues, one would think that a highly paid, highly skilled position like this would be filled by someone with training and/or experience in the field... although that hasn't stopped most of Carvalho's appointees from landing jobs with a notable lack of credentials. Sullivan has proved his worth to Carvalho simply through his ability to stick to the guns of his higher-ups, as evidenced by his stick-to-it-ive-ness in taking on all comers in defending the KIUC realm. It matters not that he is a relative newcomer to the island or that he is a not "local"- usually a negative for patronage hires under Carvalho. It matters only that he is ready, willing and able to act as a human shield for arrows directed at his boss. We like Ben. He's the nicest of guys and actually we're sure he actually believes in what he says and what he does. It's likely he will bristle at this analysis of why he got his "dream job." But given the history of the hiring practices since Carvalho took office just over three years ago, it's hard to come to any other conclusion. .

KIUC/FFP denied by FERC

SOURCE: Brad Parsons (mauibrad@hotmail.com)
SUBHEAD: FERC says KIUC/FFP plans are type of unwarranted “claim-jumping.” The Kekaha Ditch proposals have been dismissed.  

Through Secretary Kimberly D. Bose on 20 October 2011 for FERC - (http://islandbreath.blogspot.com/2011/10/kiucffp-denied-by-ferc.html)


Image above: Mashup by Juan Wilson of claim-jumper bushwhacking gold-pannner. From (http://www.usa-printables.com/Events/19th_century/1800-events-021.htm).
 
[Editor's note: This appears to be excellent news. The following is the content of the FERC PDF file of the dismissal of the KIUC/FFP Kekaha Ditch proposals. This is a long document. For a gist read just red highlighting by IslandBreath. Get if here - (www.islandbreath.org/2011Year/10/111020fercruling.pdf)].

 137 FERC 61,057 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION Before Commissioners: Jon Wellinghoff, Chairman; Philip D. Moeller, John R. Norris, and Cheryl A. LaFleur. Commissioner Spitzer is not participating. Kahawai Power 4, LLC Project No. 14105-000 Kekaha Ditch Hydro, LLC Project No. 14203-000 ORDER DISMISSING PRELIMINARY PERMIT APPLICATIONS (Issued October 20, 2011)
1. This order dismisses applications by Kahawai Power 4, LLC (Kahawai Power) and Kekaha Ditch Hydro, LLC (Kekaha Ditch Hydro) for preliminary permits to study the feasibility of a hydropower project on the Kekaha Ditch Irrigation System near the town of Waimea, Kauai County, Hawaii.

 I. Background A. Historical Background
2. The Kekaha Ditch Irrigation System is located in the Kekaha region, which is located in the western portion of the island of Kauai and consists of a broad lowland coastal plain below upland mountains.[1] Historically, the Kekaha Sugar Company leased over 12,000 acres in the region from the State of Hawaii and used the Kekaha Ditch Irrigation System to irrigate its sugar cane fields. [2] On February 28, 2001, the Kekaha Sugar Company ceased operations and the lands reverted back to the State of Hawaii. [3] On September 16, 2003, a state executive order granted management and control over the agricultural land formerly leased to the Kekaha Sugar Company to the Agribusiness Development Corporation (Development Corporation), which is administratively part of Hawaii’s Department of Agriculture. [4]

 3. On April 1, 2008, the Development Corporation and the Kekaha Agricultural Association (Agricultural Association) entered into a Memorandum of Agreement under which the Development Corporation authorized the Agricultural Association to manage, operate, maintain, and control the agricultural land. [5] Specifically, the authorization to the Agricultural Association covered (1) the drainage and ravine resources, (2) the road and roadway resources, (3) the electrical power resources, and (4) the irrigation resources, as well as all facilities and equipment accessory to those infrastructures. [6]

 4. On April 15, 2010, the Agriculture Association and Pacific Light & Power, the parent company of Kekaha Ditch Hydro, executed a Memorandum of Understanding under which the Agriculture Association granted exclusive rights to Pacific Light & Power to develop long-term renewable power generating systems on the agricultural lands. [7] Since that time, Kekaha Ditch Hydro has consulted and coordinated with the Agricultural Association in its efforts to pursue development of a 2-megawatt (MW) project (Kekaha Project 2). Specifically, in May 2010, Pacific Light & Power applied to the Development Corporation for authorization to access the property on which the Kekaha Project 2 is to be located and to use the waterways thereon. The application for access was approved at the Development Corporation’s September 15, 2010 board meeting, and the authorization was granted on April 15, 2011. [8] Subsequently, Kekaha Ditch Hydro began a feasibility study of the Kekaha Project 2 and completed a preliminary project study, including a timeline, required State and local permitting, and a financial model. [9]

 5. The commercial operation date for the Kekaha Project 2 is targeted for 2016. [10] Before commencing operation however, Kekaha Ditch Hydro will need to complete the remaining steps in Hawaii’s hydropower authorization process. This process includes the requirement to obtain permits that address natural resources, water quality, recreation, historical sites, and project safety.  

B. Applications before the Commission
6. On March 1, 2011, Kahawai Power, a private development company, filed an application with the Commission for a preliminary permit under section 4(f) of the Federal Power Act (FPA)11 to study the feasibility of the proposed 1.5-MW Kekaha Waimea Water Power Project No. 14105 (Kekaha Project 1). The proposed project would use the Kekaha Ditch and would be located at the same site and use the same water resource that Kekaha Ditch Hydro is developing. [12]

7. On March 23, 2011, the Commission issued public notice accepting the Kekaha Project 1 application for filing and soliciting comments, motions to intervene, and competing applications. [13] The County of Kauai, the Development Corporation, Pacific Light & Power, Inc., and the Agriculture Association filed timely motions to intervene. [14] The Department of Hawaiian Home Lands filed a late motion to intervene that was granted by notice issued on September 30, 2011. Comments were filed by Pacific Light & Power, Inc., the Agriculture Association, the Kingdom of Hawaii, and the U.S. Department of the Interior.

8. In its motion to intervene, the Development Corporation stated that it opposes Kahawai Power’s application because the priority status afforded to the holder of a preliminary permit could interfere with its decisions on further development and improvement. The Agriculture Association added that if the Commission issues a preliminary permit for the Kekaha Project 1, the Association, as the manager of the Ditch facilities and related lands, would have to expend time and resources addressing a project that it asserts is not compatible or integrated with its current development plans. Further, the Agriculture Association stated that such a preliminary permit would disrupt ongoing initiatives supported not only by the Agriculture Association, but also by Hawaii state government agencies, stakeholders, and local community members. The Agriculture Association cautioned that the achievement of important state policy objectives concerning diversified agriculture and renewable energy may be unnecessarily hampered or delayed by granting a preliminary permit.

 9. On May 20, 2011, Kekaha Ditch Hydro filed a competing application with the Commission for a preliminary permit to study the feasibility of the Kekaha Project 2 No. 14203, the same project that Kekaha Ditch Hydro is developing through Hawaii’s state hydropower authorization process. [15] On July 22, 2011, the Commission sent a letter to Kekaha Ditch Hydro requesting additional information. Kekaha Ditch Hydro filed the requested information on August 16, 2011. The Commission did not issue public notice accepting the application for Kekaha Project 2. The Department of Hawaiian Home Lands has, however, filed a motion to intervene.

 II. Discussion
10. Given that Hawaii’s electrical generation and transmission system is not connected to the interstate electric grid, Part I of the FPA applies in a different manner to State of Hawaii inland hydropower projects than to those located in the contiguous United States. Accordingly, as discussed below, many hydropower projects in Hawaii do not require a Commission license, and Hawaii has a long history of authorizing and regulating hydropower projects at the state level. [16] There are no Commission-licensed hydropower projects in Hawaii.  

A. The Commission’s Hydropower Jurisdiction
11. Under the FPA, the Commission has two types of licensing jurisdiction: mandatory and permissive. Mandatory licensing is governed by section 23(b)(1)17 of the FPA, which provides that a Commission license is required for a hydroelectric project if it: (1) is located on navigable waters of the United States;18 (2) occupies lands or reservations of the United States; (3) uses the surplus water or water power from a government dam; or (4) is located on a non-navigable commerce clause stream, affects the interests of interstate or foreign commerce (e.g., is connected to the interstate power grid), and has undergone construction or major modification after August 26, 1935.19

 12. Section 23(b)(1) of the FPA provides, in pertinent part:
It shall be unlawful for any person, State, or municipality, for the purpose of developing electric power, to construct, operate or maintain any dam, water conduit, reservoir, power house, or other works incidental thereto across, along, or in any of the navigable waters of the United States, or upon any part of the public lands or reservations of the United States . . ., or to utilize the surplus water or water power from any Government dam, except under and in accordance with . . . . a license granted pursuant to this Act. Any person . . . intending to construct a dam or other project works across, along, over, or in any stream or part thereof, other than those defined herein as navigable waters, and over which Congress has jurisdiction under its authority to regulate commerce with foreign nations and among the several States, shall before such construction file declaration of such intention with the Commission, whereupon the Commission shall cause immediate investigation of such proposed construction to be made, and if upon investigation it shall find that the interests of interstate or foreign commerce would be affected by such construction such person . . . shall not construct, maintain, or operate such dam or other project works until it shall have applied for and shall have received a license under the provisions of this Act. If the Commission shall not so find, and if no public lands or reservations are affected, permission is hereby granted to construct such dam or other project works in such stream upon compliance with State laws.
13. If the conditions described above are not met, FPA section 4(e) [20] nevertheless permits the Commission to license a hydroelectric project in response to a voluntary application if the project is located on a commerce clause water. [21] Permissive licensing is authorized rather than required, and is governed by section 4(e) of the FPA. Section 4(e) authorizes licensing of hydroelectric projects located on a broader class of commerce clause waters than are specified for projects that would require licensing under

14. Section 4(e) of the FPA provides, in pertinent part:
The Commission is hereby authorized and empowered-- . . . (e) To issue licenses . . . for the purpose of constructing, operating, and maintaining dams, water conduits, reservoirs, power houses, transmission lines, or other project works necessary or convenient for . . . the development, transmission, and utilization of power across, along, from, or in any of the streams or other bodies of water over which Congress has jurisdiction under its authority to regulate commerce with foreign nations and among the several States, or upon any part of the public lands and reservations of the United States . . ., or for the purpose of utilizing the surplus water or water power from any Government dam. . . .
15. reservations of the United States or uses surplus water or water power from a Federal government dam, the determination of whether licensing is required will generally turn on a navigability finding. This is because, although a newly-proposed project in Hawaii will involve post-1935 construction and may be located on a commerce clause waterway, it will not be connected to the interstate transmission grid. Absent a finding that the project would affect the interests of interstate or foreign commerce in some other fashion, i.e., the presence of commercially significant anadromous or diadromous fish,24 the jurisdictional determination will hinge on a navigability finding. In making jurisdictional determinations for projects proposed in Hawaii, the Commission has found that, based on the evidence presented in those cases, there was insufficient evidence of navigability or [22] This broad class of commerce clause waters consists of those that are subject to the jurisdiction of Congress under its authority to regulate interstate and foreign commerce. These include headwaters and “tributaries of river systems necessitating supervisory power to preserve or improve downstream navigability or water commerce generally.” FPC v. Union Electric Co., 381 U.S. 90, 97 (1965). They also include other bodies of water that are not conventional streams, such as groundwater. Swanton Village, 70 FERC at 61,996. Unless a proposed hydropower project in Hawaii occupies public lands or of impacts on commerce to find that proposed hydroelectric projects require a Commission license. [25]

16. While those projects did not require a Commission license, [26] they may have been subject to the Commission’s permissive licensing authority under section 4(e). Section 4(e) authorizes the Commission to license hydroelectric projects located on commerce clause waters, i.e., any bodies of water over which Congress has jurisdiction under its authority to regulate commerce. Because most, if not all, of Hawaii’s rivers ultimately flow into the ocean, they would be considered commerce clause streams, which are a subset of section 4(e) commerce clause waters. Consequently, most hydropower project developers in Hawaii could seek a voluntary Commission license pursuant to section 4(e).

17. Section 4(f) of the FPA [27] authorizes the Commission to issue preliminary permits for the purpose of enabling prospective applicants for a hydropower license to secure the data and perform the acts required by section 9 of the FPA, [28] which in turn sets forth the material that must accompany an application for license. Section 5 of the FPA [29] provides that each preliminary permit shall be issued for the sole purpose of maintaining priority of application for a license under the terms of the FPA. This means that a preliminary permit holder has first-to-file priority in the event that two or more developers file a license application with the Commission.

18. The Commission’s jurisdiction to issue a preliminary permit stems from our jurisdiction to license the proposed project; if we would have jurisdiction to issue a license, we would also have jurisdiction to issue a preliminary permit. [30] In the case at hand, neither Kekaha Project 1 nor Kekaha Project 2 is located on lands or reservations of the United States or uses surplus water or water power from a government dam. Nothing in the record indicates that either of the projects is located on navigable waters of the United States, and although the projects would be built after August 26, 1935, and located on a commerce clause stream, we cannot conclude, based on the record, that either project would affect the interests of interstate or foreign commerce. Based on the information available, licensing is not required for Kekaha Project 1 or Kekaha Project 2.

19. Although licensing would not be required for Kekaha Project 1 or Kekaha Project 2, the Commission would be permitted under section 4(e) to issue a license since the Kekaha Ditch draws water from the Waimea River (which flows into the ocean), and is therefore located on a commerce clause waterway. Consequently, the Commission is authorized to issue the preliminary permits sought in this case.

 20. Given that the Commission appears to have jurisdiction to issue a license for either of the proposed projects, it is unquestionable that it has authority to issue preliminary permits with respect to those projects. [31] However, it is within the Commission’s sole discretion to decide whether to issue a preliminary permit. [32]  

B. The Preliminary Permits at Issue
21. The Commission has historically exercised significant discretion in processing preliminary permit applications. The Commission has issued preliminary permits for terms ranging from 18 months to 3 years, and has at times decided not to issue preliminary permits for an entire class of technologies, i.e., those projects that have a generating capacity under a certain threshold. [33] More recently, the Commission has agreed, in a Memorandum of Understanding with the Department of the Interior, to not issue preliminary permits for hydrokinetic projects located on the Outer Continental Shelf. [34] Such decisions are within our authority, so long as we provide adequate justification for them. Examining the facts in the cases before us leads us to conclude that, while the Commission cannot envision every set of facts that may be presented to it, as a general matter we will decline to issue preliminary permits for projects in Hawaii that would be subject to permissive section 4(e) licensing, unless the facts of the particular case present extenuating circumstances that would require the Commission to consider such an application.

 22. As explained above, Kahawai Power filed the Kekaha Project 1 preliminary permit application for a site that another developer, Kekaha Ditch Hydro, was already pursuing through Hawaii’s state hydropower authorization process. Were we to issue a preliminary permit to Kahawai Power, the company would then have first-to-file priority over Kekaha Ditch Hydro, even though that entity has been working with state authorities to develop a project at the same site. This appears to us to be a type of unwarranted “claim-jumping.” Because the issuance of a preliminary permit is within our discretion, we decline to do so here. Moreover, in order to avoid similar situations in the future, we will, as a general matter, decline to issue preliminary permits for projects in Hawaii that would be subject to permissive section 4(e) licensing. This proceeding demonstrates the potential for the Commission’s preliminary permitting process to interfere with hydropower development that is proceeding in accordance with a legitimate state authorization process.

 23. We note that filing a complete preliminary permit application with the Commission is significantly less demanding than the substantial efforts that appear to have taken place here under the state development process. Thus, the potential for a preliminary permit issued by the Commission to interfere with existing development activities at the state level is significant. While we cannot let a state process interfere with our exclusive mandatory jurisdiction, we do not want our preliminary permit program with respect to projects subject to permissive licensing to chill the development efforts of entities pursuing a legitimate state authorization process. 24. Nor do we want to force developers of projects not subject to mandatory licensing to engage in the federal authorization process when they have been successfully pursuing authorization from the state, simply because another entity has filed a preliminary permit application with the Commission for the same hydropower site.  

25. As discussed above, we henceforth will, as a general matter, decline to issue preliminary permits for projects in the state of Hawaii that would be subject to permissive section 4(e) licensing. To ensure that the issue of our jurisdiction is properly considered, future applicants seeking a preliminary permit for a project in Hawaii will need to make an initial showing demonstrating why licensing under FPA section 23(b) would be required for the proposed project. 26. Based on our reasoning above, the preliminary permit applications for the Kekaha Project 1 and Kekaha Project 2 are dismissed. The Commission orders: (A) The preliminary permit applications filed on March 1, 2011, and May 20, 2011, by Kahawai Power 4, LLC and Kekaha Ditch Hydro, LLC for the Kekaha Waimea Water Power Project No. 14105 and the Kekaha Ditch Hydropower Project No. 14023 are dismissed. (B) This order constitutes final agency action.

Any party to this proceeding may file a request for rehearing of this order within 30 days from the date of its issuance, as provided in section 313(a) of the Federal Power Act, 16 U.S.C. § 825l (2006), and section 385.713 of the Commission’s regulations, 18 C.F.R. § 385.713 (2011).  

Footnotes
 [1] Kekaha Agriculture Association May 20, 2011 Intervention at 3. The Kekaha Ditch Irrigation System has been in use since 1907 and was initially comprised of 16 miles of ditches, tunnels, flumes, and a siphon in Waimea Canyon and four miles of ditch in the lowland coastal plain area. The ditch was subsequently extended eight miles further in the lowland area. The Kekaha Ditch Irrigation System originates with two intakes on tributaries to the Waimea River (at the 850-foot elevation) in the Waimea Canyon and a third intake on the Waimea River (at the 550-foot elevation). At the 700- foot elevation in Waimea Canyon, the water crosses the Waimea River from west to east through a penstock. The ditch continues seaward on the eastern side of the Waimea Canyon and then again crosses the Waimea River through a 2,190-foot-long, 48-inch diameter steel siphon. Kekaha Agriculture Association Intervention at 5-6.  

[2] Agriculture Development Corporation April 9, 2011 Intervention at 3 and Pacific Light & Power May 20, 2011 Comments at 2. 

[3] Kekaha Agriculture Association Intervention at 4. 

 [4] Agriculture Development Corporation Intervention at 3 and Kekaha Agricultural Association Comments at 4. The Development Corporation is also responsible for the Kekaha Ditch Irrigation System, including water rights and the ground beneath the ditch, pursuant to a subsequent state executive order. 

 [5] Kekaha Agricultural Association Comments at 5. 

[6] Agriculture Development Corporation Intervention at 4. 

[7] Kekaha Agriculture Association Intervention at 11.

 [8] Pacific Light & Power Intervention at 5. Since that time, PLP has been a non- voting member of the Agriculture Association. 

[9] Pacific Light & Power Intervention at 6. 

[10] Pacific Light & Power Intervention at 5.

 [11] 16 U.S.C. § 797(f) (2006). [

12] The proposed Kekaha Project 1 would have the following facilities: (1) a 30-foot by 8-foot intake structure on the existing Kekaha Ditch; (2) a 2,180-foot-long, 36-inch-diamter steel penstock (sections to be buried); (3) a 40-foot-long by 55-foot-wide powerhouse containing a single 1.5-MW turbine generator with a maximum hydraulic capacity of 50 cubic feet per second, and an adjacent substation; (4) a 35-foot-long, 10-foot-wide tailrace channel that dischargers project flows to the Waimea River; (5) a new 610-foot-long, gravel road to access the powerhouse; (6) a 2-mile-long, 69-kilovolt (kV) transmission line interconnecting the project’s substation to the existing Kaumakani substation; and (7) appurtenant facilities. The estimated annual generation of the Kekaha Project 1 would be 8.7 gigawatt-hours (GWh).  

[13] Notice reproduced at 76 Fed. Reg. 17,413 (2011). 

 [14] Timely, unopposed motions to intervene are granted by operation of Rule 214 of the Commission’s rules of practice and procedure. 18 C.F.R. § 385.214 (2011). 

[15] The proposed Kekaha Project 2 would have the following facilities: (1) an intake structure on the existing Kekaha Ditch with an automated control gate to manage flows and a trash rack; (2) an approximately 900-foot-long, 42-inch-diameter high density polyethylene penstock (likely to be laid above ground); (3) a concrete powerhouse with a 15-foot floor elevation containing a single 2-MW Pelton turbine and generator and an adjacent substation; (4) an approximately 1000-foot-long, 4-inch- diameter high density polyethylene tailrace that dischargers water to the Waimea River; (5) a 2-mile-long, 12-kV transmission line, interconnecting with an existing distribution line on Kekaha Agricultural Association property; and (5) appurtenant facilities. The estimated annual generation of the Kekaha Project 2 would be 8.9 GWh. 

 [16] Thirteen hydroelectric plants in Hawaii have been identified, with 18 generating units producing a total annual average of 91.6 GWh of electricity. See Hydroelectric Power in Hawaii- A Reconnaissance Survey, (February 1981), available at http://hawaii.gov/dbedt/info/energy/publications/hydro81.pdf. The Wailuku River Hydroelectric Power Company began producing electricity at an additional site in May of 1993. Department of Business, Economic Development & Tourism, Use of Hydropower in Hawaii, http://hawaii.gov/dbedt/info/energy/renewable/hydro (last visited Sep. 28, 2011). As of 2009, the average annual production of state-regulated hydropower projects had increased to 112.64 GWh. U.S. Energy Information Administration, Hawaii Electricity Profile (Data Release Date: April 2011), available at http://www.eia.gov/cneaf/electricity/st_profiles/hawaii.html. 

[17] 16 U.S.C. § 817 (2006).

 [18] The definition of “navigable waterway of the United States” is found in section 3(8) of the FPA, 16 U.S.C. § 796(8) (2000). “Navigable waters” means those parts of streams or other bodies of water which are used or suitable for use for the transportation of persons or property in interstate or foreign commerce.  

[19] The post-1935 construction requirement stems from the specific language and legislative history of section 23(b)(1). See Farmington River Power Co. v. FPC, 455 F.2d 86 (1972). [20] 16 U.S.C. § 797(e) (2006). 

[21] Swanton Village, 70 FERC ¶ 61,325, at 61,992-93, 61,995-96 (1995). If the conditions described above are not met, FPA section 4(e)20 nevertheless section 23(b)(1). [22] Thus, it is possible for a voluntary applicant to obtain a license under section 4(e) of the FPA for a project that would not require a license under section 23(b)(1). [23]

 [23] See Cooley v. FERC, 843 F.2d 1464, 1471 (D.C. Cir. 1988). 

 [24] See, e.g., United States Department of Commerce v. FERC, 36 F.3d 893 (9th Cir. 1994) (finding mandatory jurisdiction can be based on project’s commerce clause impact on anadromous fish). 

 [25] See, e.g., Kauai Island Utility Coop., 117 FERC ¶ 62,073 (2006) (licensing is not required for the Upper and Lower Waiahi Hydroelectric Project because there was insufficient evidence to determine that the South Branch North Fork Wailua River, Waikoko Stream, Waiaka Stream, Iliiliua Stream, and Waiahi Stream, near Lihue, Kauai County, Hawaii, are navigable waters); Island Power Co., 47 FERC ¶ 61,355 (1989) (licensing is not required because, in light of the totality of the record evidence, the Wailua River had not been shown to be a navigable water of the United States at the site of the proposed project); Island Power Co., 42 FERC ¶ 62,129 (1988) (licensing not required because a navigation status report for the Hanalei River found that that river is not navigable at the site of the proposed project) reh’g denied, 75 FERC ¶ 61,126 (1996) (licensing is not required because even though the Commission has recognized that a project’s effect on anadromous fish could affect interstate commerce, the record here demonstrated no commercial significance of several native Hawaiian species of anadromous fish, shrimp, and snails). [26] Note, however, that offshore marine hydrokinetic projects would require licensing because they are located in navigable waters. See AquaEnergy Group, Ltd, 101 FERC ¶ 62,009 (2002).

 [27] 16 U.S.C. § 797(f) (2006). 28 16 U.S.C. § 802 (2006). 29 16 U.S.C. §798 (2006).

 [27] 16 U.S.C. § 797(f) (2006). 

[28] 16 U.S.C. § 802 (2006). 

 [29] 16 U.S.C. §798 (2006).  

[30] Hanalei Power Company, 53 FERC ¶ 61,167, at 61,619 (1990); Swanton Village, 70 FERC ¶ 61,325, at 61,992 (1995). 

 [31] The Commission may dismiss a permit application where it determines that it lacks jurisdiction over the proposed project. See, e.g., San Carlos Irrigation and Drainage District, 105 FERC ¶ 61,134 (2003) (dismissing permit application for project at federal dam site where Commission had no jurisdiction over development of private hydropower).

 [32] See Karmargo Corporation v. FERC, 825 F.2d 1392, 1398 (D.C. Cir. 1988) (stating that the Commission, “under the Federal Power Act, is not obliged to issue permits to anyone who seeks them”).

 [33] The first set of regulations promulgated under the FPA stated that preliminary permits would not be issued “for projects of a power capacity of less than 100 horsepower.” Regulation 9, FPC Order No. 9 (February 28, 1921). The capacity of the projects subject to the provision was later changed to 2000 horsepower. See FPC Rules and Regulations, Second Revised Issue (1924); FPC and Regulations, Fourth Revised Issue (1931); 18 C.F.R. § 4.80 (1979). This provision was dropped from the Commission’s regulations in 1979 following the passage of the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978. [34] Memorandum of Understanding Between the U.S. Department of the Interior and Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, signed April 9, 2009. .

KIUC/FFP Outreach Con Job

SUBHEAD: Meetings to build understanding on how these projects will be permitted and be constructed.

By Vanessa Van Voorhis on 29 September 2011 for Garden Island -  
(http://thegardenisland.com/news/local/article_64a5133a-ea6d-11e0-8acd-001cc4c002e0.html)

  
Image above: Presentation of "Enron: The Play" at the Royal Court Theatre. From (http://www.e-flux.com/journal/view/209).  

Free Flow Power is preparing for its first round of community outreach meetings on its proposed hydroelectric projects for Garden Isle waterways on behalf of Kaua‘i Island Utility Cooperative.
“Our goal is to be able to work our way around the island and get as many people as possible,” FFP Project Development VP Jason Hines told KIUC’s Board of Directors on Tuesday.

The first meetings will be with select community groups, followed by “extensive” community outreach meetings for the public, he said. The dates of the meeting are yet to be determined.

“In our opinion, things are moving according to plan. A lot has been going on over the last two months, really much of it in direct response to the board and staff’s wishes for more expansive outreach,” Hines said.

“We’ve been talking with a lot of agencies, talking with a lot of people on the ground, landowners, and discussing the projects and the sites and learning what we can about their concerns and how to reflect that in the project layout and project design,” he said.

In late 2010 and earlier this year, FFP filed preliminary permit applications with FERC to develop hydropower facilities on six Kaua‘i waterways. To date, FERC has approved four of the six applications: 6.6-megawatt Wailua River Hydroelectric Project (Clean River Power 15); 3.5-MW Hanalei River Hydroelectric Project (Kahawai Power 1); 6.6-MW Makaweli River Hydroelectric Project (Kahawai Power 2); and 2-MW Wailua Reservoir Water Power Project (Kahawai Power 5).
Applications are still pending for the 1.5-MW Kekaha Waimea Water Power Project (Kahawai Power 4) and the 7.7-MW Kitano Water Power Project (Clean River Power 16).

Some of the projects have been changed slightly, Hines said, and some more significantly. He said FFP is learning about opportunities to integrate the projects with agriculture and existing infrastructure.

“Looks like some of the projects may be a little smaller than originally conceived, and the details of that will be sorted out over the next month or so,” Hines said, adding a goal is to present a first-recommended or first-proposed project layout designs in late October or early November.

“Hopefully, we’ll have the first version of a proposal that KIUC can bring to the public and discuss at that point in time,” he said. “It will be a starting point for an additional round of feedback, shaping the project. That’ll be the first point in which there will be some drawings and a written description responsive to the feedback we get.”

KIUC Board member Ben Sullivan suggested that a schedule of meetings be presented to the public as soon possible.

“You need to inform the public of the meeting dates and times and provide a description of the meeting and include key issues, so people know what to expect going in,” Sullivan said.

“Primarily, it’s going to be an opportunity for people to ask questions, give responses, comments,” FFP Project Specialist Dawn Huff said.

Sullivan also asked that FFP provide a timeline for the projects over the next two to three years “so people know where they stand.”

“That’s a little difficult to do until we get more clear with the state agencies,” Huff said. “I think we can get to that, but we’re not quite there yet.”

Hines said, “Along the way, we’ll try to lay out what the intended schedule is. As the process unfolds, it becomes more clear.”

Meanwhile, FFP will be hosting a workshop today in Honolulu with numerous state agencies to discuss federal processes, including those of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, and how it will tie into state permitting requirements.

The meeting is “to build some understanding on how theses projects will be permitted and what will be needed to move them forward to construction,” Hines said.

See also:
Ea O Ka Aina: KIUC's Smoke Filled Room 6/18/11 .

KIUC Petitioners PUC Request

SOURCE: Elaine Dunbar (nunyabus@gmail.com) SUBHEAD: Update on dialog between the Representatives of KIUC Petitoners and office of Rep. James Tokioka. [Editor's note: This issue is not over. More correspondence on this subject can be read here (110804kiucpuc.pdf)] Image above: The Simpson's line up for Enron Ride. The Scummiest Guys in the Room article from (http://www.absurdandreport.com/2011/04/enron-scummiest-guys-in-room.html). By Tek Nickerson for Representatives of KIUC Petiton - KIUC held their regularly scheduled Board meeting yesterday, Tuesday, 7.26.11. In response to the Members' Second Petition and strong request for a verifiable count of signatures, KIUC simply issued a statement, defining a valid signature vs an invalid signature, plus a restatement of the count. They completely sidestepped the question about verification and that they might have a vested interest in protecting their own privacy how the determination was made on each signature. I was the only one from the public signed in to talk, which was first on the agenda. Chairman Phil Tacbian said only members could talk and they could only talk in items on the agenda for three minutes. I was called "to the stand." I introduced myself as the point person on the second petition (to recall the election). The chairman said the petition was not on the agenda, and therefore COULD NOT BE DISCUSSED, so I could not talk. I thanked him and sat down, setting my precedence for respect. (It was later explained to me that items are put on the agenda five days prior to the meeting. The agenda is posted on the KIUC web site. Since Tuesday was the sixth day after they received the petition, they CHOSE to avoid the issue by ignoring it on the agenda.) I sat and listened as each person at the table gave their report. Consulting Counsel Proudfoot reported that he advised the Board how to proceed in response to the Second Petition. Paraphrasing:
"A point of order, Mr. Chairman! Mr Proudfoot just brought the subject of the Second Petition to the table! I may now speak on the subject!" "No, you may not."
This is the second time the Chair CHOSE to be dismissive. Steve Raposo, Vice Chair and chairman of the Members Relations Committee, did not mention the Second Petition in his report. This was the third time that a KIUC elected representative chose to ignore their commitment to being open and reaching out to the public. During a break, Consulting Counsel Proudfoot approached Director Jan TenBruggencarte and me. He said he was intending to tell Jan something to tell me. Finding me pleasant and inviting his advice, he said that I could ask the Chair to wave the rule and allow me to speak. This is encouraging, especially coming from him. We showed each other we were reasonable men and could work with each other. Raposo's Members Relations report centered on defining exactly what their course of action would be for outreach with the public. After ten minutes of discussion, it was still a quandary for them what it would look like. Knowing that Raposo probably categorized me as an unreasonable obstructionist, I approached him with a suggestion. He was a bit taken aback, but he listened. I reminded him that history has taught us the approach that works under similar circumstances: the Dolley Madison solution of giving weekly parties for opposing political sides in the neutral territory of her home. I.e. Take the budget for talk-down "dog and pony shows" and apply it to island-wide regional parties, where the public is attracted first by the food and then by the opportunity to ask questions of their elected directors and opposing views one-on-one. Raposo listened. Time will tell if he is receptive to Dolley Madison's ingeniously iconic solution, used in the White House to this day. Raposo is one of the Gang of Five, who controls the direction that the board votes. (About the First Petition, he reportedly remarked that some people are only obstructionists. This is the third opportunity they passed up.) At each opportunity ANY one of the directors could have interjected an objection...and did not. The three up for re-election are Ben Sullivan, Stu Burley and Steve Raposo. Jan explained that if we vote out Stu and Steve with strong candidates, we'll have purged the Gang of Five with our own Five Alive. This is the light at the end of the tunnel. Meanwhile, sitting in the back of the room for a while was Free Flow Power representatives, Jason Hines and his assistant, Dawn. The chairman invited them to report an update on their progress. THIS WAS NOT ON THE AGENDA. Then we all took a break before they went onto Executive session. I took the opportunity to complain to Ben Sullivan that FFP should not have been given the floor, since they weren't on the Agenda. Ben said he let it go, because they wouldn't be taking a vote. That's contrary to their own rules! Thus, there is NO WAY in which the situation can be "corrected" if the Board can continue to "pick and choose" what it can do accordingly. Will KIUC consider the "possibility" of a forum approach in getting to the root of the matter discussed in a neutral venue with an opportunity for both sides of the issue to be in the planning process of determining what should be discussed and how both sides can be fairly presented? >
July 18, 2011 Kauai Island Utility Cooperative David Bissell, President & CEO T. Phil Tacbian, Board Chairman 4463 Pahee Street, Suite 1 Lihue, Hawaii 96766 Dear President Bissel and Board of Directors, KIUC members recently placed their names on a second petition under the heading: KIUC CO-OP MEMBERS PETITION TO RECALL THE BALLOTS AND REDO THE ELECTION, in response to the first petition. On July 13, 2011 through the Garden Island Newspaper we learned: “Kaua‘i Island Utility Cooperative on Wednesday announced that an insufficient number of valid signatures was submitted on a second petition received by the cooperative on Monday…At the completion of the verification process by KIUC and legal counsel. It was determined that of the 291 signatures submitted 185 were valid, requiring no further action by the KIUC Board of Directors,” a KIUC news release states. The statement that no further action is required by the board is the same dismissive attitude that brought about the first and now, second petition. Petitioners were surprised at the extremely high number of invalidated names reported, 106 according to your count alone. Over 2,000 members have questioned your recent decisions; in all fairness a legitimate obligation exists to follow through for these members who took the time to voice their opinion in a democratic process afforded by their KIUC By-laws, Article II, Sections 2 & 6, in accordance with the Hawaii Revised Statutes. In order for members to satisfactorily be assured that the verification process was handled in an independent and unbiased manner, we are requesting confirmation through: 1) A copy of the report with your findings that reflect a. how you conducted the verification process, b. who counted the petition names and c. if a third, independent party was involved. 2) A copy of the petition with page number and line item or checks in front of the names / signatures / addresses / account numbers that were deemed invalidated. 3) Please state the reason for each invalidation. We see this as a reasonable expectation in a democratic process and essential in putting to rest any lingering doubt about discrepancies. As well, this would be a clear indication that the mutual interests and responsibilities are transpiring with clarity, transparency and accountability in our shared quest to build trust. Please provide this information within 5 working days, addressed to: PETITIONERS C/O Tek Nickerson 6978-b Kokeanu Place, Kapaa, HI 96746 With kind regards,
Representatives of KIUC Petitioners Jonathan Jay Tel: 808-634-6267 Scott Mijares Tel: 808-652-7113 Ken Taylor Tel: 808-823-8527 Jose Bulatao 337-9135 Tek Nickerson Tel: 808-822-4795 6978-b Kokeanu Place Kapaa, HI 96746 .

Kauai's Hydro Battle

SUBHEAD: The bad blood between KIUC members and its board over hydroelectric plans continue to boil.  

By Joan Conrow on 22 June 2011 for the Honolulu Weekly -  
(http://honoluluweekly.com/cover/2011/06/kauais-hydro-battle/)

 
Image above: Illustration of Wailua River dammed for front of Honolulu Weekly and Joan's cover story. 
  
Farmer Jerry Ornellas bristled when he read in the local newspaper that Kauai Island Utility Cooperative (KIUC) was looking to develop a hydroelectric project on the Wailua reservoir. It was the first he’d heard of it, and that rankled, considering he was president of a water users cooperative whose system includes the reservoir. “They know who we are,” Ornellas said. “You’d think they would have given us the courtesy of a call. But they never said a word.”

The Robinson family was equally vexed to discover they had not been consulted on plans to study hydro on land in western Kauai they have owned for more than a century. Conservationists, meanwhile, were outraged to learn that a twice-bitterly-beaten-down plan to dam the Wailua River apparently had been resurrected.

Thus began KIUC’s clumsy foray into hydroelectric development under a federal process that allows investors to stake a claim, gold rush-style, on rivers and irrigation ditches. The utility actually followed the lead of Free Flow Power (FFP), a Massachusetts-based consortium of consultants and investors that filed the permit applications that created a community uproar. The utility became embroiled when it bought Free Flow’s permits and hired the firm to guide it through a hydro development process administered by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) in Washington, DC.

It’s a process that has been attempted in Hawaii, but never completed, and Sen. Daniel Akaka has unsuccessfully sought legislation to prevent its use in the Islands. The core concern is whether the FERC process will respect the state’s progressive water code, particularly its instream flow standards, which determine the quantity, flow and depth of water required to protect the various uses of a specific stream. Others wonder if federal bureaucrats–given their unfamiliarity with Hawaii’s unique cultural, environmental and historical characteristics–can be reasonably expected to set the right standards. Whether or not Hawaii residents can effectively participate in a proceeding based in Washington, DC has yet to be determined.

For all those reasons, KIUC’s decision to take the FERC route has raised suspicion and resistance. But the secrecy surrounding the initial applications, and uncertainty about exactly what might be developed, has also fed the opposition. KIUC claims it is too early to discuss project plans, and regardless of what Free Flow wrote on the applications, it is not going to build any dams. “These permits just give us the right to do feasibility studies,” says David Bissell, chief executive officer of KIUC, a member-owned utility cooperative. “We are just at the very preliminary stages of trying to see what’s possible.”

Hindu Monks Oppose

Not everyone is convinced. “All we have to go on is what’s in their applications,” said Rev. Arumugam Katir, a monk at Kauai’s Hindu monastery. The monks, who normally eschew political activism, are vigorously opposing the utility’s proposed hydro projects on the Wailua River, which runs through the monastery’s grounds and feeds the East Kauai Water Users Cooperative they helped to form.

FERC opponents are leery of both Free Flow and the process that brought it into a relationship with KIUC. “Free Flow Power has never done hydro development,” said Adam Asquith, a taro farmer and Universiy of Hawaii Sea Grant extenson agent on Kauai.

Keeping the Flow

Bissell maintains that the non-profit utility cooperative will benefit from having FFP manage the process, which he says offers insurance that KIUC will not be edged out by a private developer who would charge more for any electricity generated. He also says that without FERC, hydro has no future at KIUC. “I would not recommend we go forward investing possibly millions of dollars without the FERC process because a for-profit developer could jump in front of us,” Bissell said.

To stake its own claim, KIUC purchased the shell companies that FFP formed to file six applications on waterways from Hanalei to Kekaha. FERC has already approved three, giving KIUC preliminary permits that carry the exclusive right to study hydroelectric development for three years. Bissell said no specific price was placed on the applications, which were purchased as part of a larger consulting contract. The utility has refused to disclose the full value of the contract, which includes an incentive for delivering completed projects, but KIUC attorney David Proudfoot said FFP will be paid “several million dollars if none go past the first stage.”

In response, Asquith led a petition drive that is forcing KIUC to put its FFP contract to a vote of its members, with ballots being mailed out this week. Although FERC opponents have little money for advertising, the monastery funded a full-page informational ad in the Kauai newspaper, and citizens have used social media and the Island’s community radio station and public access television station to take their message to co-op members.

Navigating the Waters

Meanwhile, the East Kauai Water Users Cooperative, County of Kauai, Department of Hawaiian Home Lands (DHHL) and State Agricultural Development Corporation filed formal petitions to intervene in the FERC permits, and the state attorney general’s office apparently plans to take similar action.

“Why go to Washington, DC, to decide how Hawaii streams are managed?” said William Tam, deputy director of the Hawaii Commission on Water Resources and Management. “It is hard to understand some facts when you’re 5,000 miles away. Written statements do not always tell the whole story.”

Tam has taken no stand on the current KIUC permits. The matter may come before the Water Commission, and he has not thoroughly reviewed the applications. But he is familiar with FERC from his earlier tenure in the State attorney general’s office. Between 1989 and 1991, the State opposed FERC jurisdiction over three proposed hydroelectric projects for the upper and lower Wailua River and the Hanalei River.

The State objected on the grounds that the projects were not located on “navigable waters,” as provided under the Federal Power Act, and that FERC would assert its authority over in-stream flow standards. The State Water Code vests that authority to the State Water Commission, which is charged with managing Hawaii’s stream water–a public trust resource–for cultural, ecological and economic purposes.

While a California court recognized FERC’s authority to set instream flow standards and another court upheld the State of Washington’s right to set Clean Water Act standards, those questions remain untested in Hawaii, because no FERC hydro project has ever been built in the Islands.

However, the issue of FERC jurisdiction has been addressed, at least in part. On June 2, 1989, FERC ruled that it had no jurisdiction over a proposed “lower Wailua” project–a diversion dam about 1,000 feet upstream from Wailua Falls with a powerhouse about .9 miles upstream of the Fern Grotto–because “the Wailua River has not been shown to be a navigable water at the site of Island Power Co.’s proposed project.”

On July 18, 1991, FERC issued an order stating that federal licensing was not required for Island Power’s proposed “upper Wailua” project–again because the site was not on “navigable waters.”

License to Flow

In 1990, however, FERC ruled that it had the authority to issue “voluntary licenses” for a proposed project on the Hanalei River because it constitutes “Commerce Clause waters.” These are defined as “any waterway within the United States…where…water will ultimately end up in public waters such as a river or stream, tributary to a river or stream, lake, reservoir, bay, gulf, sea or ocean either within or adjacent to the United States,” which is true of virtually all streams in Hawaii.

Developers ultimately dropped all three projects, leaving unanswered the question of whether federal or state interests prevail.

In light of these decade-old orders, Tam said, it is not correct for KIUC to claim that the FERC process is required for the Wailua River. Nor is it accurate to claim that FERC is the only way to secure priority for a project. “The applicant will have to obtain an option or a lease from the landowner at some point,” he said. “Do it up front. No one else will be able to use the property.”
Asquith said the KIUC Board could “level the playing field” simply by passing a resolution refusing to buy electricity from any project developed under a FERC permit.

KIUC officials say it is too early in the process to sign a lease or obtain an option, because they are uncertain which locations may bear fruit. Besides, they say, FERC offers the benefit of a clear roadmap for developing hydro, which is lacking at the state level. “It’s a well-defined, transparent process that requires intensive involvement by all stakeholders,” Bissell said. “It gives stakeholders a seat at the table on these important resources people feel very passionate about. It’s really not a way to circumvent the state process.” KIUC board members also have vowed to secure all the state permits needed for a hydro project.

While the FERC process is relatively common in the western United States, Tam does not believe it is appropriate for Hawaii. First, the methodology for determining stream flows on the Mainland is “very different” than what is used in Hawaii, he said. There is also the distance factor. “There just is not a similar ability to participate. You have to go to Washington to participate in hearings about what is happening in Hawaii streams. We think those kinds of decisions should be made here.”

Isaac Moriwake, an Earthjustice attorney who has litigated water use issues on Maui, agrees. “Hawaii has very strong and nationally recognized protections regarding stream flows and Native Hawaiian rights. That stands to be completely wiped out by what KIUC is doing, and it seems they’re doing it for that purpose,” he said.

A Matter of Trust

The (DHHL) raised similar concerns in its intervention request. “Hawaii law grants DHHL priority over other users of the State of Hawaii’s water resources, including water in the East Kauai Irrigation System, which encompasses the Wailua Reservoir. In addition, a preliminary permit would afford [KIUC] certain priorities that may interfere with DHHL’s current and future development of the area’s hydrologic resources.”

Asquith was also disturbed by that prospect. “Water in Hawaii is a highly provincial resource, hydrologically, socially, culturally–even the rain has a different name in each valley,” he said. “It is impossible to convey the depth of the value of water to someone who hasn’t taken time to understand it. The FERC bomb was just this horrific breach of protocol that was shocking to me.”

The insensitivity displayed by KIUC and FFP, both of which failed to consult key players before filing permit applications, and the prospect of working through a federal process that he termed “more procedural than substantive” motivated Asquith to mount the petition drive.

In addition to forcing a vote on the FFP contract–ballots must be cast by July 8–the petition drive also required KIUC to host a general membership meeting, which was held June 4. More than 100 people attended. Most expressed concerns, grievances and reservations in testimony that spanned the better part of a day.

“I support hydro, but in good conscience, how can I vote yes when I don’t know what it’s going to entail, is all I’m saying,” testified Mark Sueyasu, who identified himself as a west Kauai hunter.
Puanani Rogers said the utility should have met with Native Hawaiians before moving forward, prompting Bissell to reply that such consultation “is very high on our priorities.”

“You’ve run off down this road in secret…without having the community on board, and I think that’s the core of your problem,” said Les Brosnan, who noted that in its earlier forays into alternative energy, KIUC “chose weak partners that are still flailing around and have failed to deliver.”

Some, however, urged KIUC to move ahead. Among them was Councilwoman JoAnn Yukimura, who said she believes that ending the Free Flow contract “will stop our in-house efforts to develop hydro.”

That spurred others to address Bissell’s desire to “get the discussion out of the FERC process and into hydro,” which apparently prompted the utility to distribute hand-held paper fans that read “hydros” on one side and “yes!” on the other.

“KIUC has successfully blurred the reason for this meeting,” said Elaine Dunbar, who helped collect petition signatures. “It’s not about hydro. It’s about secrecy and an improper process.”

Criticism about the process spilled over into KIUC’s approach to the upcoming vote, including its preparation of a “voter guide” that focused on hydro, with no reference to the petitioners’ concerns about FERC. Petitioners said it seemed unreasonable that KIUC had written the pro and con arguments.

KIUC attorney Proudfoot disagreed. “The Board voted for [the Free Flow contract]. They are entitled to support it. They are not required to help others who don’t support it with the member’s money. That’s why it’s clearly labeled ‘KIUC voters guide.’”

Despite edging petitioners out of that particular process, and acknowledging past failures with consultations, KIUC officials said they are fully committed to carefully considering public concerns as they explore hydroelectric development. “This is a decision that will be made in this community, by this community,” said KIUC director, Jan TenBruggencate.

Bissell offered his own exhortations at the meeting. “I encourage everyone to have trust in KIUC, have trust in your elected board, have trust in me and, most importantly, have trust in yourself. The only way these projects will go forward is through overwhelming community support.”

Therein seems to lay the crux of the conflict.

“If KIUC cannot conduct a single meeting in a manner which addresses the acknowledged intent of the petition and the clear interest of the people attending, how can they possibly conduct complicated community interactions on hydro?” Asquith questioned, in a widely circulated email. “If they cannot refrain from shameful ballot propaganda that completely distorts the intent of the petition and vote, how can they possibly deliver a balanced presentation on hydro?”

Or as Kapaa resident Glenn Mickens noted during a break in the meeting: “There’s only one reason we’re here. It’s a matter of trust. From the get-go, there’s this underlying mistrust for KIUC.”
And overcoming that mistrust ultimately may prove more difficult for the utility than successfully developing hydroelectric under any process.

Plenty water but no kokua

With one of the world’s wettest places at its summit, Waialeale receives 424 inches of rain each year. Many of Kauai’s numerous streams derive from the lush hilltop, feeding sugar and pineapple plantations and generating the hydroelectric power that ran the plantations’ mills and camps.

McBryde Sugar Co. built a plant on the north shore’s Wainiha River in 1905 that continues to generate about 3.6 megawatts of power for Kauai Island Utility Cooperative, while also serving the needs of Kauai Coffee. Seven smaller systems–five of them privately owned–produce another 5 megawatts for the utility. Together, they account for about 15 percent of the island’s total power generation.

While several hydro projects were proposed for the Wailua and Hanalei rivers in recent decades, they were all stalled by environmental concerns, community opposition and funding problems.

Questions on ‘invalid’ KIUC signatures

 By Leo Azambuja on 20 July 2011 for the Garden Island - 
  (http://thegardenisland.com/news/local/article_11b340c0-b36d-11e0-aa26-001cc4c002e0.html)  

 In a lengthy battle between the island’s utility cooperative and some of its members, the light switch continues to flip up and down.

Earlier this year Kaua‘i Island Utility Cooperative announced an agreement with Free Flow Power to explore hydroelectric development.

A petition signed by more than 300 co-op members generated a ballot question asking if the board’s decision should stand. On July 8, more than two-thirds of voting members affirmed the board’s action to hire FFP.

A second petition, organized by Kaua‘i resident Jonathan Jay, asked KIUC to recall the ballots for the first petition and redo the vote. He criticized the co-op for not providing its members with fair and balanced information for the vote.

Each petition must contain at least 250 signatures from co-op members. The second petition gathered 291 signatures. But KIUC said 106, or 36 percent, were invalid, so the petition was rejected.
In the latest turn of events, five island residents serving as “Representatives of KIUC Petitioners” challenged the co-op’s decision to deem the signatures invalid.

“Petitioners were surprised at the extremely high number of invalidated names reported,” said group representative Tek Nickerson in a letter mailed Monday to KIUC CEO David Bissell.
“They’re probably not members,” KIUC spokeswoman Shelley Paik said Wednesday when asked why some of the signatures were invalidated.

Nickerson said for members to “satisfactorily be assured that the verification process was handled in an independent and unbiased manner,” the group requested a copy of the report with KIUC’s findings reflecting how the verification process was conducted, who counted the petition names and if a third, independent party was involved.

The group also requested a copy of the petition with marks showing which signatures didn’t count, plus a reason for each invalidation.

“We see this as a reasonable expectation in a democratic process and essential in putting to rest any lingering doubt about discrepancies,” Nickerson said in the letter. “This would be a clear indication that the mutual interests and responsibilities are transpiring with clarity, transparency and accountability in our shared quest to build trust.”

Paik on Wednesday checked with Bissell’s secretary to see if KIUC had any response to RKP’s letter. Bissell’s secretary acknowledged receiving the letter, Paik said, but had been in meetings all day and had not had a chance to go through her mail before leaving work.

“She hasn’t opened it yet, so she doesn’t know what it says,” Paik said.

The group asked KIUC to provide answers by Monday.

The RKP members listed in the letter are Nickerson, Jay, Jose Bulatao, Ken Taylor and Scott Mijares.

.

Another Reason to vote NO!

SOURCE: Ken Taylor (taylork021@hawaii.rr.com) SUBHEAD: History tells us to vote "NO" on KIUC/FFP deal with FERC. Today is the deadline. By Glenn Mitckins on 7 July 2011 for the Garden Island - (http://thegardenisland.com/news/opinion/mailbag/article_1071abc6-a84f-11e0-81ef-001cc4c002e0.html) Image above: Kauai Electric box from the old days. From (http://www.flickr.com/photos/luckycomehawaii/5771975533/). In this highly charged, controversial issue of getting greater hydro power on Kaua‘i — we now have six minor operations going — let’s examine an aspect of the plan that has not been adequately discussed. We hear from Kaua‘i Island Utility Cooperative the word “trust, trust, trust” over and over. But let’s move back about 10 years when KIUC was in the process of buying Kaua‘i Electric from Citizens Utility and see exactly why or if we should trust what KIUC is proposing to do today. In 2001, a group led by Greg Gardner held a series of meetings around Kaua‘i telling the people that $285 million was the best price at which KE could be bought. Based on strenuous objection from some of our citizens and the Consumer Advocate, the Public Utilities Commission rejected that price. However, in 2002, the PUC approved a $220-million price that was still $50 million over the KE book value. Actually, we noted the ‘Ele‘ele plant that was being bought was a rust bucket and the only good assets we got for this outrageous price were the power lines that had been destroyed by Hurricane Iniki. As a side note, Citizens Utilities’ stock soared on the big board after dumping KE to KIUC — interesting! But back to “trust.” The same investment banker who was part of the “best price deal” in selling KE is an integral part of the Free Flow Power/Federal Energy Regulatory Commission deal being proposed today! And the same legal counsel that was there to advise KIUC in 2001 and 2002 is still the one giving legal opinions to the KIUC Board of Directors and CEO today! If past history is a lesson, we need to heed. Then, with all due respect to our KIUC CEO, we must vote “no” on this ballot measure. As a co-op, we the rate-paying members are the owners. As such, we deserve a voice, and our views should have been included in the Voters Guide, in addition to the self-serving position penned by KIUC management. Nearly everyone wants hydro power on Kaua‘i, as we desperately need to get off the fossil-fuel kick. But, as Kaipo Asing so often said, this whole issue is about the process, and this process has been skewed from the get go. .

KIUC Ferc Flim Flam

SUBHEAD: The $325-400,000 we stand to lose in a "no" vote is peanuts compared to the cost of a "yes" vote down the road.  

By Andy Parx on 30 June 2011 for Parx News Daily - 
  (http://parxnewsdaily.blogspot.com/2011/06/following-money.html)

 
Image above: A reproportioned photo of Kauai's Secluded Falls. From Apollo Kauai masthead (http://apollokauai.wordpress.com).

 In addition to our wholesale advocacy of a "no" vote on this FERCin' mess KIUC has gotten us into with their capitulation to Free Flow Partners' (FFP) extortion, we've been doing quite a bit of retail, taking a slew of phone calls from people for whom computers are anathema- all essentially asking "WTF?". Many just want an answer as to whether to vote "no" or "yes." But far more have read both the newspaper articles and the ballot itself along with KIUC's unbelievably slanted voters' guide. Under "your no vote means" the guide makes the claim that:
The contracts with FFP will be terminated, and all preliminary permits will revert back to FFP. This will make progress on hydro in the near term very difficult and more expensive, and more than $325,000 in contractual obligations will be due to FFP.
Even those that have read both our coverage and Joan Conrow's awesome Honolulu Weekly article and meticulously researched and presented Gold Diggers (parts 1 and 2) blog posts have asked an important question. Basically they ask "well, yes- the whole deal stinks and we should never have entered into any deal with FFP. But now that we have we stand to lose $325,000 (some reports claim it's as high as $400,000) which will inevitably show up on our bill. And we will have paid that money and not be any closer to hydroelectric power project development. Shouldn't I vote 'yes?'"

The answer to the first part is that while yes, it will cost hundreds of thousands to cancel the deal with FFP, many have not heard or glossed over a quote from Conrow's Honolulu Weekly piece which says that: 
 Bissell said no specific price was placed on the applications, which were purchased as part of a larger consulting contract. The utility has refused to disclose the full value of the contract, which includes an incentive for delivering completed projects, but KIUC attorney David Proudfoot said FFP will be paid “several million dollars if none go past the first stage." 
Given the opposition to FERC and the likelihood that, with the state's long-standing opposition and threats to sue, we will never proceed to full FERC licensing. What a yes vote means is that, although we'll have to forfeit the $325K we'd potentially be throwing away a lot more. As Conrow concluded in her second Gold Digger post:
In its permitted applications, FFP states, “The studies will be financed by the applicant.” No mention is made of KIUC. For each project, FFP estimates the cost of doing all the first-year studies — the feasibility stuff — at $100,000. The rest of the work — consultations, developing a notice of intent and pre-application document, and beginning scoping activities — is estimated to “not exceed $500,000." So even if FFP were to take all six projects all the way up to the license application, it would cost no more than $3.6 million. KIUC won’t tell us exactly what we’re paying, but KIUC attorney David Proudfoot told us at the June 4 community meeting that FFP will be paid “several million dollars if none go past the first stage.” Several is defined as “more than or three but not many.” So it sounds like we’re paying close to, if not more than, the full estimated price for bringing all six projects through the first stage, even though KIUC CEO David Bissell and some Board members have acknowledged that some of the projects will never get off the ground.
On top of that, FFP will get an incentive for delivering completed projects. The second question is a bit trickier but perhaps more revealing. The reason why KIUC says it is going through the FERC is that there is no state process for developing hydro. But we must remember a couple of things.

What many including petition initiator Adam Asquith have said, is that what we should have done- and should do- is to go to the state and say "we want to do hydroelectric projects and want to work with the state to establish a system for development and introduce and pass enabling legislation and eventually administrative rules so that we can develop environmentally and culturally sensitive and water-wise projects into the future.

And, as a matter of fact, a good place to start is the KIUC ballyhooed flow chart that FERC has already developed for public participation and alter it for our unique water laws. Certainly we're not the only ones in the state who want to develop hydropower. HELCO has the same renewable energy portfolio requirements as KIUC for the other islands.

If and when they wake up to the insanity of their "Big Wind" project and the fact that it is doomed to failure, hydroelectric is probably the next best technology in terms of cost of both development and future rates. But whether through pure laziness, corruption or pure stupidity the KIUC board of directors and administrative staff seems hell bent on committing us to a costly and widely-opposed way of going about it- one that, even if it were to succeed, would still leave us without a simpler, less costly statewide system for the next round of hydroelectric development.

The $325-400,000 we stand to lose in a "no" vote is peanuts compared to the cost of a "yes" vote down the road. Whether as a way to say no to FERC or to, in fact, SAVE us money, a "no" vote is the best option to get us out of this mess that the board of KIUC has gotten us into. That and remembering this fiasco during the next KIUC board of directors election.

See also:  
Ea O Ka Aina: Say NO! to KIUC/FFP Deal 6/13/11


 .

On the KIUC/FFP Subject

SOURCE: Ken Taylor (taylork021@hawaii.rr.com) SUBHEAD: Kauai Island Utility Coop and its members - Oh there was fear. Oh there was loathing. By Andy Parx on 27 June 2011 for Parx News Daily - (http://parxnewsdaily.blogspot.com/2011/06/while-were-on-subject.html) Image above: TVA dam in Knoxville, TN, built using eminent domain to remove local residents. From (http://knoxvilletennesseerealestateblog.com/2006/09/30/tva-does-a-policy-180/). But the when KIUC CEO David Bissell "debated" anti-FERC petition originator Adam Asquith at a packed Kapa`a Library conference room on Saturday there was mostly misdirection and stonewalling on Bissell's part- especially when we asked about the origins of KIUC's dealing with Free Flow Partners (FFP). We decided to confront Bissell as to how exactly the deal came about, quoting a Honolulu Weekly article by Joan Conrow that made pretty clear that FFP had gotten the preliminary Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) permits, set up shell corporations and then held a gun to KIUC's head forcing them to either deal with FFP to get dibs on the exclusive right to develop six water runs on Kaua`i for hydroelectric or FFP would tie up the rights indefinitely. Bissell at first denied that the permits were issued before KIUC's initial involvement (which Bissell said was last October) something documentation reveals to be a lie. But then, when we were allowed a followup question, he refused to say who exactly approached whom and how the deal was struck other than saying an unidentified intermediary brought the parties together, saying "what difference does it make?". We approached Bissell after the meeting seeking to get some answers to that matter as well as a couple of others. But Bissell as soon as we approached him as he spoke to others, quickly scurried to his car, saying he would not answer any more questions and leaving us, note pad in hand, chasing him through the library parking lot. So what is the truth? Well, according to Conrow's blog post today, the truth is that "FFP had already done the “poaching” by filing its applications for hydro projects on Kauai waterways prior to entering into a contract with KIUC." Not only does she clarify and reiterate what we suspected she was saying on Friday but she details how "it appears the circumstances that led to their union were more akin to a shotgun wedding than a love match. What’s more, it seems that “grab 'em with both hands” is FFP’s standard MO." Seems that, although FFP hasn't developed a single project as opponents have reiterated, they have scooped up hundreds of these "preliminary permits" across the country including "141 project sites covering all but a few miles of (an) 850-mile reach of the (Mississippi) river" causing FREC "to decline to issue additional permits on this stretch of river, and instead allow potential developers to advance their projects through the commission's licensing process." Another part of their scam seems to be to find existing dams without any hydro projects and get permits for exploring exclusive development. While we suggest you read Conrow's post today for all the gory details of that and other FFP mainland scams, what remains is yet another reason to distrust Bissell himself and everything that comes out of his mouth. The other questions we didn't get answered included one as to why the "members" of the co-op aren't entitled to examine full Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) between KIUC and FFP which, as far as we have been able to determine by asking board members, is "confidential" for no particular reason other than it's confidential. One thing that Bissell refused to say was whether KIUC would commit to abandon the seeking of full FERC licensing, in light of the contention of late that KIUC/FFP has only obtained "preliminary permits" to look into hydroelectric projects on Kaua`i and not full "FERC licensing"- the latter of which is opposed by the state DLNR's water division chief and attorney general's office. It's particularity irksome that Bissell has claimed that, because there is no state process for hydro development, we need to follow the "FERC process" contained in a flow chart that was waved about at the dais. But he avoided commenting on why that process couldn’t be followed without FERC. Could it be that the reason why KIUC never approached the state to set up a state-based process for developing hydro was because FFP had already gotten the preliminary permits and was holding a gun to KIUC's head saying that they would hold up any hydro development indefinitely unless KIUC signed on the dotted line? That would sure explain a lot of things such as why all of a sudden without any advance notice KIUC was suddenly gung ho for hydroelectric development. It would also explain why they signed an MOA that "purchases" the permits and shell corporations but allows both to revert to FFP should KIUC change its mind, as will happen should the ballots be returned with more "no" than "yes" votes. We had prepared a question for Bissell on the off-chance that we would get a second round at the meeting along the lines of "given that almost everyone- including some board members- agrees that your communications with the public have so far been severely bungled with a lack of transparency, the 'no FERC, no hydro' threat and the refusal to release the MOA, is there anything you'd personally do differently if you had it to do over?". But after the a couple of hours of misinformation, threats, misdirection and, when necessary, stonewalling in reiterating all the past bunk we've been fed, the question seemed to have answered itself. See also: Ea O Ka Aina: Say No! to KIUC/FFP Deal 6/13/11 Ea O Ka Aina: TVA to build Nukelettes 6/22/11 .